The Smilist - Professional dental clinic exterior with modern facilities

The Smilist

Unclaimed
4.8 (719 reviews)

Dentist in New City, NY

Call Now

About

Michael Rothstein, DDS - An Affiliate of The Smilist is part of a large, multi-state dental support organization. It operates as a modern clinic, offering a wide range of general, cosmetic, and specialty dentistry services. The Smilist brand emphasizes a high-quality patient experience, modern technology, and a compassionate team of dentists. They focus on providing comprehensive dental care to communities in New York and surrounding states.

Hours

Monday

9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Tuesday

9:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Wednesday

9:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Thursday

9:00 AM – 6:00 PM

Friday

8:00 AM – 4:00 PM

Saturday

8:00 AM – 1:00 PM

Sunday

Closed

Quick Info

Address

16 Squadron Blvd #105, New City, NY 10956

Phone

(845) 634-8866

Website

thesmilist.com

Detailed Introduction

The Smilist is a prominent dental support organization (DSO) that has grown to be one of the leading providers of dental care in the Northeast. Founded in 2014, the brand operates a network of over 110 dental offices across several states, including New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, Delaware, and Maryland. The Michael Rothstein, DDS office in New City, NY, is an affiliate of this larger organization, adopting the brand's patient-focused model. The clinic, also known as The Smilist New City, provides a full spectrum of dental services, ranging from general dentistry like cleanings and fillings to more specialized treatments such as cosmetic dentistry, oral surgery, and emergency services. The practice is known for its modern, state-of-the-art facilities and a team of highly-rated dental professionals. The Smilist aims to create an exceptional patient experience by focusing on convenience, offering online booking, flexible hours including evening and weekend appointments, and accepting most major dental insurance plans. Dr. Michael Rothstein, who has been practicing dentistry in New City, NY, since 2009, is the principal dentist at this location and has a background in both general practice and prosthodontics.

Photos

The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist
The Smilist

Patient Reviews

4.8 out of 5
Sandra Leiser

Sandra Leiser

Let me first say that the dental techs and Dr. Forker are great. I have hated every dentist office have ever been to because they are rough and painful. This office is the opposite - gentle and explains things and offers support for a patient with anxiety. My MAJOR issue is with whoever is in charge of billing and the customer service associated with it. I started using this office last August for the first time because my husband went there and he raved about Dr. Forker, knowing how much I didn't like going to the dentist. So I decided to try it out. I had my own insurance and was also covered by my husband's insurance.

Even though my husband was an established patient, they claime to have some problem seeing his insurance and over my first two visits charged me over $700 which I paid because they told me they would get it straightened out and and get me a refund once the insurance was applied. It is now nearly a year later - at which point the insurance company will no longer issue a payment - and they have NEVER gone and sent in the claim. I have called COUNTLESS times, I have called their corporate office, their customer satisfaction department, inquired at the reception desk, emailed the office, YOU NAME IT. . . I have tried it. In the last 11 months that I have been trying to get this resolved it was only in MAY when said person finally called me one time claiming she'd never heard of the issue. I was BEYOND patient and made the mistake of giving her a few days to look into it and get back to me. And since then.

. . RADIO SILENCE. That was also the ONE AND ONLY time anyone ever deemed to get back to me out of the many times I reached out for help. My husband now refuses to see them anymore either until this is fixed. If you are going to this office, I sincerely hope you have all your financial ducks in a row. I paid them IN GOOD FAITH because they provided me services and I am an honest person. They have now refused to complete the basic level of paperwork to submit the claims to get reimbursement to me and they owe me HUNDREDS of dollars!! It's beyond poor business and absolutely terrible customer service.

July 9, 2025

Juan Fernandez

Juan Fernandez

I had a fantastic experience with my dental hygienist, Dennis! He was incredibly thorough yet gentle during the cleaning, ensuring my comfort throughout the entire process. I also appreciated his expert advice on proper oral hygiene, which was both insightful and easy to follow.

His friendly and professional demeanor made my visit enjoyable. If you’re looking for top-notch care, I highly recommend Dennis!

March 11, 2025

D F

D F

Thus far, nothing but POSITIVE vibes and results from the entire crew of this office. Everyone conducts themselves in a professional manner and my experience has been a welcoming change from that of other dental practices. Thank you. And I hope my future experiences stay on par with my past.

July 22, 2025

Reina S

Reina S

Everyone at Dr. Rothstein’s office is amazing. I’ve convinced my whole family to come to this practice as they have been taking such good care of us for years.

We have had two separate dental emergencies for my small kids and they have saved the day each and every time. Everyone is patient, caring, knowledgeable, and take the time to explain everything so we can stay calm. We are so grateful!!!

May 27, 2025

Leave a Review

Our Location

The Smilist

16 Squadron Blvd #105, New City, NY 10956

Contact Information

Address

16 Squadron Blvd #105, New City, NY 10956

Phone

(845) 634-8866

Website

https://thesmilist.com/new-city-dentist/

Other The Smilist Studio Locations

Ready for Your Next Dental Visit?

Make an appointment now and experience the difference.

Nearby Dental Clinics

Healthy Teeth For Life: Zivari Sohayla S DDS

Healthy Teeth For Life: Zivari Sohayla S DDS

162 NY-59, Monsey, NY 10952

Smile for Life Family & Cosmetic Dental

Smile for Life Family & Cosmetic Dental

27 Townline Rd, Pearl River, NY 10965

Smile Center of Rockland

Smile Center of Rockland

317 S Middletown Rd, Nanuet, NY 10954

Healthy Teeth For Life

Healthy Teeth For Life

162 NY-59, Airmont, NY 10952

Miriam Aronoff, D.D.S., PLLC

1 Fletcher Rd Apartment C, Monsey, NY 10952

Bridge Dental Care

Bridge Dental Care

375 W Rte 59, Spring Valley, NY 10977

Allied Dental Care

375 W Rte 59, Spring Valley, NY 10977

Spring Valley Dental Care PC

37 Kennedy Dr, Spring Valley, NY 10977